Caramel Coloring in Spirits – Myth, Truth, and Impact on Flavor

At Drinkology, we frequently receive questions about colorants and additives in spirits – especially about coloring agent E150 (caramel coloring). Many whisky and rum enthusiasts want to know whether their favorite spirits are artificially colored, whether this is permitted, and whether it affects the flavor. It’s no longer a secret that many well-known spirit brands use caramel coloring to standardize color. But why exactly is this dye used? And is it really flavor-neutral, as many producers claim? In this article, you’ll learn everything you need to know about caramel coloring in whisky, rum, and cognac.

What is Caramel Coloring?

Caramel coloring is a natural dye created when sugar is caramelized under heat. In the food industry, it is labeled with the E-number E150 and categorized into four subtypes:

E150a (Plain Caramel) – No additives, typically used in high-quality products.
E150b (Caustic Sulfite Caramel) – Contains sulfite, rarely used in spirits.
E150c (Ammonia Caramel) – Found in beer and soft drinks.
E150d (Sulfite Ammonia Caramel) – Commonly used in whisky, rum, and cognac for color consistency

For high-proof spirits, E150a or E150d is usually used.

Is Caramel Coloring Dangerous?

According to food safety authorities, caramel coloring is considered safe and approved without any maximum quantity limits. The amounts used are minimal – around 100 ml of caramel coloring per 100,000 liters of whisky

Why is Caramel Coloring Used in Spirits?

Colorants play an important role in the food industry, and spirits are no exception. The main reason for using caramel coloring is to achieve a consistent appearance.

Reasons for using caramel coloring:

Visual consistency: Consumers expect a certain color from a whisky or rum.
Consumer psychology: Darker spirits appear more mature and premium.
Marketing & brand recognition: Spirits should always look the same, regardless of batch variations

A good example is Scottish blended whiskies: their success in international markets was largely due to consumers receiving a consistent quality with the same color and flavor over the years. However, the use of caramel coloring has sparked criticism – especially since it's become known that even premium single malt whiskies may be artificially colored.

Which Spirits Contain Caramel Coloring?

Not all spirits contain caramel coloring, but it's particularly common in certain categories:

Caramel Coloring in Rum

Many dark rums derive their color not just from barrel aging but from added caramel coloring. This is especially typical in blended rums to ensure a uniform look.

Typical products with caramel coloring: Havana Club Añejo, Bacardi 8 Year, Captain Morgan Dark
Products without caramel coloring: Foursquare, Hampden Estate

Caramel Coloring in Whisky

Many Scottish blended whiskies and even some single malts contain E150d to balance color variations. This is a common practice, especially in Scotland.

Contains caramel coloring: Johnnie Walker, Chivas Regal
Without caramel coloring: Ardbeg, GlenAllachie, Bruichladdich

Caramel Coloring in Cognac & Brandy

Caramel coloring is also widely used here to give the product a uniform and appealing color. However, premium cognacs tend to rely more on barrel aging alone.

How to Recognize Uncolored Spirits

In the EU, colorants must be declared on labels. You’ll find statements like “With coloring,” “Contains E150a-d,” or “With caramel coloring.” Only older bottlings may lack this information on the label.

High-Quality Uncolored Whiskies & Rums at Drinkology

For connoisseurs seeking authentic, additive-free spirits, we offer an exclusive selection in the Drinkology shop:

Tip

Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage Single Malt Whisky 0,7L 46%

Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage Single Malt Whisky 0.7L 46% History and production of Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage: The Pulteney distillery was founded in 1826 in the north-eastern corner of Scotland and enjoys an excellent reputation among whisky lovers. The standard bottlings of the 12-, 17- and 21-year-old Old Pulteney Single Malt Whisky are extremely popular with connoisseurs and regularly receive top marks at tastings. Then, at the World Whisky Awards in March 2016, there was a sensation: the vintage bottling Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage was awarded the "Best Single Malt Whisky of the Year 2016" award, which is tantamount to an accolade in the scene. The limited edition was sold out everywhere within a very short time and is practically no longer available. We at drinkology.de are all the more proud that we can offer you the Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage exclusively in our shop. Stocks are limited, so speed is a must. It's definitely worth getting hold of it, because the Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage is more than impressive. The Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage was released in September 2015 and caused a stir shortly afterwards. The distillate was stored for a total of 26 years in former bourbon barrels made of American white oak. At first glance, this does not seem to be particularly groundbreaking. What is special, however, is that before filling at the Pulteney distillery, an intensely smoky single malt whisky was also stored in the barrels, which gives the Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage a delicate, pleasantly sweet smokiness. Bottled with 46% alcohol by volume, with no added coloring and not chill-filtered, this single malt whisky develops an incredible complexity and sophistication that is rarely seen. Taste of the Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage: The Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage shimmers amber in the glass and offers an intense, fruity bouquet. Green apples, pears and citrus fruits are initially surrounded by warm wood smoke. Oriental herbs and spices also emerge, giving the Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage a wonderfully fresh impression. Vanilla, caramel and honey round off the exceptionally harmonious aroma in the background. The quality and outstanding composition of this single malt whisky is impressively demonstrated even before the first sip. The Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage is full and intense in taste. Dark fruits, spicy oak and gentle peat smoke are present. Becoming sweeter over time, butter biscuits, toffee and freshly baked sponge cake come to the fore. Hints of coconut, leather, coffee and tart orange marmalade round off the taste impression. The finish of the Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage seems almost endless. Peat smoke, tobacco and notes of citrus fruits form the finale and remain on the tongue for a long time. With the Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage, the connoisseur can expect a wonderfully balanced composition of distillery character, barrel aromas and elegant smokiness, perfectly balanced and extremely versatile. This makes the Old Pulteney 1989 Vintage a truly exceptional whisky.

Content: 0.7 Liter (€570.00* / 1 Liter)

€399.00*

Macallan Single Malt Whisky Concept Number 2 2019 0,7L 40%

Macallan Single Malt Whisky Concept Number 2 2019 0.7L 40% Malt distillery from Speyside Another distillery located in Speyside that has been producing whisky for over 200 years is The Macallan distillery. If the company had not been lost in 1996, it would have been one of the last independent companies today, like Glenfiddich, Glenfarclas or Springbank. At that time, however, Highland Distillers made a takeover offer to the company, which was actually well below its market value. However, an earlier deal was the downfall of the entrepreneurs and they had to sell. In an earlier financial uncertainty, a 25% share was sold to the Japanese Suntory company, and Rémy also owned 1%. Highland Destillers acquired these company shares, made a pact with Suntory and from then on owned the majority of shares in Macallan. One could only hope that this takeover would not cause Macallan Whisky to lose its good reputation as the 'Rolls Royce' of whisky, but fortunately it hasn't. Today it still wins prizes in numerous tastings and record prices are paid at auctions for old Macallan bottlings. Concept No. 2 It is the second of three bottlings in the Concept series from Macallan. The special thing about this bottling is that it targets the two passions of master blender Steven Bremner. He combines whisky and music. Whisky & music, how do they fit together? Bremner says that making whisky is in some ways the same as creating a song. First, the base note must be determined, with whisky this is the basic taste, then you can build up layer by layer around it. With both products, individual elements can be changed to go either in one direction or the other. Like Concept No. 1, No. 2 was also matured in different barrels. The longer maturation phase took place in Miguel Martin sherry barrels, followed by a finish in ex-bourbon barrels. The tasting notes show aromas of toffee, stewed apples and a hint of vanilla. Oak wood and spicy notes complement the taste. The finish also clearly shows pleasantly sweet aromas, accompanied by spices and toffe.

Content: 0.7 Liter (€641.43* / 1 Liter)

€449.00*

%

Willett Family Estate Rye Whiskey 4 Jahre 0,7L 55,6%

Willett Family Estate Rye Whiskey 4 years 0.7L 55.6%

Content: 0.7 Liter (€114.14* / 1 Liter)

€79.90* €89.90* (11.12% saved)

Rum:

El Dorado Uitvlught Special Cask Finish 2006/2021 Ruby Port Casks 0,7L 55,4%

El Dorado Uitvlugt Special Cask Finish 2006/2021 Ruby Port Casks 0,7L 55,4%

El Dorado Uitvlugt Special Cask Finish 2006/2021 Ruby Port Casks 0.7L 55.4%

Content: 0.7 Liter (€278.57* / 1 Liter)

€195.00*

Foursquare Rum 2011 Cask Strength 0,7L 60%

Foursquare Rum 2011 Cask Strength 0.7L 60% Foursquare 2011 Cask Strength Mark XXIV is a 12 year old single blended overproof rum from the Foursquare distillery in Barbados. It is produced using a combination of artistic pot still distillation and traditional multi-column Coffey distillation from sugar cane molasses. This rum is only bottled when the highest quality is guaranteed and is presented unfiltered. Foursquare Rum 2011 Cask Strength 0.7L 60% is a deep amber. Aromas of grapefruit, cocoa, caramel, clove, allspice, sandalwood and a salty breeze unfold on the nose. On the palate it is powerful yet smooth, with nuances of black tea, lemon peel, molasses, spices and exotic fruits. The finish is long, dry and with subtle tannins.

Content: 0.7 Liter (€185.57* / 1 Liter)

€129.90*

Pere Labat Rhum Agricole Eleve Sous Bois Grand Diplomate 0,7L 42%

Pere Labat Grand Diplomate Agricole Rhum 0,7L 42%

Pere Labat Rhum Agricole Grand Diplomate 0.7L 42% The Pere Labat Grand Diplomate Agricole Rhum is distilled on Marie Galante from fresh sugar cane using the copper column still. This exquisite Agricole rum is a blend of 5 different rums, each of which has been aged for 3-15 years in bourbon barrels. After careful blending, they are further aged in oak barrels. The Pere Labat Rhum Agricole Grand Rum impresses with its unique taste profile with clear notes of caramel, chocolate and bitter orange. This limited bottling is limited to 3500 bottles.

Content: 0.7 Liter (€151.36* / 1 Liter)

€105.95*

👉 Discover now: Drinkology – Uncolored Whiskies & Rums

Does Caramel Coloring Affect the Flavor?

This question has sparked debate among spirits enthusiasts and experts for years. While many producers insist the amounts used are too small to impact flavor, some consumers report detecting subtle differences.

Chemical Properties of Caramel Coloring and Potential Flavor Effects

Caramel coloring is made by heating sugar with the addition of acids, alkalis, or ammonia. In the production of E150d – the most commonly used type in spirits – Maillard reactions can occur, leading to slightly bitter or caramel-like flavors. At high dosages or lower quality, a slightly burnt or metallic taste may be noticeable.
Some experts speculate that certain tannins or sulfur compounds from the E150d production process may interact with other spirit components, subtly altering the flavor. However, there is no definitive scientific proof of this.

Subjective Perception vs. Actual Flavor Impact

While chemical analyses suggest caramel coloring is flavor-neutral in standard quantities, perception plays a key role. Darker spirits are often perceived as more mature and premium, which may also affect how they taste subjectively.
However, some consumers report that whiskies with a lot of caramel coloring have a slightly artificial or bitter aftertaste. This is especially noted in budget blended whiskies or mass-produced rums, which sometimes exhibit an unpleasantly dry or astringent note.

Legal Regulations & Transparency

Labeling requirements for caramel coloring vary by country:

EU: Caramel coloring must be declared
USA: Stricter regulations, often clearly labeled

Some independent bottlers offer full transparency, explicitly marketing the absence of caramel coloring.

Is Caramel Coloring a Problem or Just a Marketing Tool?

While caramel coloring has little technical impact on flavor, it plays a major role in marketing and consumer perception.

For purists: Better to choose spirits with natural coloring.
For connoisseurs: Do blind tastings – don’t rely solely on color.

Drinkology recommends: Find a selection of high-quality, naturally colored spirits in our shop

FAQs – Frequently Asked Questions About Caramel Coloring in Spirits

What is caramel coloring (E150)?: Caramel coloring is a dye produced by heating sugar. It’s often used in spirits to balance color differences between batches
Is caramel coloring allowed in whisky?: Yes, the addition of caramel coloring is permitted and must be declared.
Does caramel coloring affect the taste of whisky or rum?: Producers claim that caramel coloring is flavor-neutral. However, some enthusiasts report a slightly bitter or caramel-like aftertaste, especially at high doses.
Why is caramel coloring used in spirits?: Caramel coloring ensures a consistent appearance and color. Darker spirits often appear more premium and mature to consumers.
How can I tell if a spirit is free from caramel coloring?: Look for labels with terms like “non-chill filtered” or “no added color.”
Is caramel coloring harmful to health?: According to food safety authorities, caramel coloring is safe and approved for use in food without quantity limits.
Where can I buy uncolored spirits?: The Drinkology shop offers a wide selection of high-quality, uncolored whiskies and rums.